I love the way C.Y is thinking about patronage in this era of oversupply and declining revenue streams for artists. I think if we can normalise patronage and productise it in a way that makes sense to users we may be able to level the playing field, especially for emerging artists who are justy starting out and don't have the support of a record label.
I recently finished Stephen Witt's book 'How Music Got Free' and one of the parts I found most fascinating was the realisation that economists started having following the rise of music piracy, that in a world of digital abundance (ie. pirating / streaming music) it becomes increasingly harder to make a profit and therefore changes the existing investment/profit relationship. Advances in technology and the emergence of the collaborative economy (read creator economy) bypass the rates of return from an investment point of view. The German Pirate Party thought that this was a positive thing and would lead to greater creativity and innovation, but it would force musicians out of the marketplace and into relationships of patronage.
I think we are starting to see this play out decades later and I'm all for it. I don't see music as a commodity that has an ROI attached. I see it as a collection of cultural artefacts that provide a snapshot of the zeitgeist at any given time in history. It doesn't relaly make sense to me that these artefacts are being evaluated in the same way a startup might be.
I recently finished Stephen Witt's book 'How Music Got Free' and one of the parts I found most fascinating was the realisation that economists started having following the rise of music piracy, that in a world of digital abundance (ie. pirating / streaming music) it becomes increasingly harder to make a profit and therefore changes the existing investment/profit relationship. Advances in technology and the emergence of the collaborative economy (read creator economy) bypass the rates of return from an investment point of view. The German Pirate Party thought that this was a positive thing and would lead to greater creativity and innovation, but it would force musicians out of the marketplace and into relationships of patronage.
I think we are starting to see this play out decades later and I'm all for it. I don't see music as a commodity that has an ROI attached. I see it as a collection of cultural artefacts that provide a snapshot of the zeitgeist at any given time in history. It doesn't relaly make sense to me that these artefacts are being evaluated in the same way a startup might be.
goes hard 55555 $enjoy
so good.... 55555 $enjoy
so beautiful 55555 $enjoy
goes hard 50000 $enjoy
beautiful 50000 $enjoy
this is f*cking incredible... 77777 $enjoy
beautiful 50000 $enjoy
50000 $enjoy
it’s go time 175864 $enjoy
all the feels 50000 $enjoy
I could feel the bass through my floor 50000 $enjoy
50000 $enjoy Melbourne mentioned
feels 50000 $enjoy
love it 50000 $enjoy
200000 $enjoy
beautiful 55555 $enjoy
yes man.... yes 50000 $enjoy
this is so chaotic and beautiful 111111 $enjoy
such a happy friday 50000 $enjoy
big love man, this hit me hard 500000 $enjoy
lovely 22222 $enjoy
yesssssss 111111 $Enjoy
so nice 22222 $Enjoy
best onchain mix i've come across so far 22222 $Enjoy
⌐Ⓗ-Ⓕ ⌐Ⓗ-Ⓕ ⌐Ⓗ-Ⓕ 22222 $Enjoy ⌐Ⓗ-Ⓕ ⌐Ⓗ-Ⓕ ⌐Ⓗ-Ⓕ
Ad-Vantage 22222 $Enjoy
such a cool project… 55555 $Enjoy
this is amazing 22222 $Enjoy
those drums... 22222 $Enjoy
Such a dope track... 22222 $Enjoy