I should mint a video showing the contrast of how much reach & love this same video received when posted to instagram verses the “post to earn” ghost town 🫂
I’ve already briefly touched on my trajectory In terms of artist long before trader, defi bridge hopping sh*t coin trader before artist onchain, Navigated both of those in parallel, trading being a private practice to sustain as a means to allow the art side to be absent of urgency in terms of being a means to survive. As a pretty active participant in both lanes. There was never a coin (beyond eth & boomer coin) that had my attention, yet my multiple wallets have traded sh*t coins across all chains, even abandoned ones. Sh*t coin is a broad stroke but meme coins absolutely land on the same canvas. I’ve made a lot of money on coins, & lost even more. Regardless of direction, none of that was conviction based or attention based, beyond the attention of time spent playing pvp trying not to be on the losing side of zero sum. Because it lacked emotion, attention, conviction…. I could allow myself to play zero sum battle ship know that a win for me is a loss for another. Which brings us to Art…. And let’s be honest. Zora is an art platform. How we got here doesn’t change that. It’s an art platform that couldn’t scale to its ambitions or to the expectations of those funding, so the hard pivot to ::insert air quotes:: “social platform”. Before that hard pivot lived the tip meta. The tip meta, helped to transition Zora from “art platform” to platform that now has incentives to be gamed. Enter an influx of ai generated memes for your chosen or multi tipping tokens because hey, why not spin up multiple burner wallets to try and capture value of seeing these tipping tokens of effortless ai images also playing a little PvP, resulting in seeing some very niche, inside an already niche and in no way relatable to anyone outside of holding those tipping tokens. Doing high value numbers in contrast to art. Now that’s out of the way. Present day. Zora being the poster child of having a skitzo identity crisis. Aims to scale outside of art is valuable, and niche images of green arrows & purple top hats, “Hey, look over here! You earn instead of just getting likes for your photo of your morning coffee mug… he’ll, you can even earn from created ai imagery of what otherwise would be just a quickly snapped nature photo…. At the same time jeckle is trying to get Becky the influencer to transition from ig for her daily posts, Hyde is snickering proudly holding its kerosene flickering lantern, In a cobble stone alleyway wearing an oversized trenchcoat whispering about the lesser known underworld, vaguely alluding that beneath every upload, whether highly intentional artwork, ai generated horse or daily photo at brunch is a market. Even if they are unaware, there could be people playing zero sum PvP on thier photo of fig on toast with some people winning and others losing While you’re not even aware of where or how to access this world to participate.. the farthest from mass adoption possible. Every post is a market, every post is a meme…. Attention, value…. From 4chan message boards to tumblr, a golden shibu pup & Saturday night live…. No meme has ever truely captured my attention, no token not attached to media has ever been something I’d ever emotionally connect to. And when multi media is attached to token, the last thing on mind is playing zero sum battle ship. I just want to collect one and hold it forever. I’m not even emotionally invested in the subject I’m addressing. Haha. I however am nostalgic about the blog era & appreciate the mind, creative works & experimentation of tokens designed to initiate discussions. Hence my participation any time one of these posts manages to win the RNG roll and actually reach me…. I participate by actually taking the time to articulate in long form. In closing: The reason zora is 100% not a social platform is because, no one can directly reply to this comment. No alert, Once I click mint, This will locked in wallet out of sight out of mind. Even the initial poster of this, will have to pay to comment If they do reply. I’ll never know.. because the poster will have moved onto to thier next post. Attention, Value….. nothing retains attention, emotional value on a 72hr maximum retention cycle…. This was fun 🫂
The issue isn't as simple as bots / boosts are good or bad. The "nefarious" part that everyone seems to keep leaving out is the most important part. It's the reason why I after several calls with David, I emotionally and actively stopped using or acknowledging the platform. It's the reason I've been pushing back so hard and so loudly about the changes to zora, removing the chronological follower and discover feeds, and having them replaced by activity feeds... If you want to pay to create fake demand, using bots, more power to you... I'd personally just airdrop actual humans I think might enjoy the music/art but "perceived volume" and all that jazz. THE ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM is why this ugly... Sound has a leaderboard, and they removed, the real time minting feed, by design they destroyed discoverability of all those new artists they shilled a brighter future to on tiktok and ig, and they never stood a chance, but a guy with a turtle neck controls those charts.... The same issue is now on zora, where unrealistic amount of mints keep going to the platforms posts, big projects, and friends of the inner circle... all of these things are fine in a free market, but when you manipulate discovery, and design to amplify the most active, and bury everyone else...... you can't gaslight me to make me believe the ones designing and calling the shots aren't intelligent enough to understand how broken and rigged that is.... I know without a doubt, it was by design at sound, i spoke for hours with David. It's becoming increasing more difficult to not look at Zora in the same light. They are devs, they could easily create an organic default feed that only shows original posts in the order they were minted from the people you follow and create a second feed, that has the activity mechanics.... the only reason not to do this, is as exactly how it looks, and i've screenshot and documented so many examples that's it's happening... So when I see promo about how Zora is fun, mints are better than likes, it feels like the same playback, trying to onboard a bunch of new users, who will be buried by the latest AI generated meme......
It's not bots, it's the whole picture. It's not speculation, it's not salt, it's actively happen to point it's impossible not to see.
Am I the bad guy for bringing up a design flaw that so many others see and label it as "the rich get richer" scheme... This behavior on sound was detrimental the ecosystem.. So it's not the bots, it's a insider strategy that is easily abused, that doesn't just benefit the the ones getting high volume, but makes the experience for everyone else feel and look bad....
Everyone is so passive in this space, these aren't defi trading ponzi's, these are platforms centered around art, that actively market themselves as superior to the web2 experience... your integrity gotta be on empty if you try and shun the messenger for trying to stick up for the greater good of health of all users....
I don't even wanna work on music or document art after all this, so I pivoted and began documenting in detail this whole experience to create and actual documentary.
No one wants to acknowledge users justified critiques, but steady reposting untrue glazing statements...
tisk tisk... Naurdwuar on the case...... INCOMING
111111 $enjoy
Music NFT's actually changed my life after 3 decades of releasing through major and indy labels and diy. Saddened by the state of the virtual experience across the board, blockchain chasing adoption and volume for protocol fees turned what felt magical into a worse feeling experience than web2... but no matter the noise, no matter the narrative, Music NFT's changed my life for the better so i'll be eternally grateful. 175,448 $enjoy
Appreciate you adding to the convo. I would assume at this point, the platforms (obviously the main pain point for most creatives and artists) already are fully aware how bad this all feels for artists and creatives but also realize there aren't enough real humans using the platforms to keep the lights on, so everyone is rushing to change what made this all special in an attempt to try to scale with hopes of mass adoption, when we aren't ready for that clearly. And it seems like the ones making the calls think the ability to "possibly" make income for uploading compared to legacy web2 social is the thing that would be so intriguing to already skeptical normies, whom if did magically all onboard rn, would quickly realize, they jumped into a new ecosystem minus their existing following only to land in a void that just adopted the same broken discovery mechanisms where following and having followers have no meaning... sustainability, income are a bonus, the majority of creatives I've crossed path with the past 30 years main concern beyond the creative process is their art making meaningful connections. This mass pivot to obviously farm creatives and users for frequent traffic i can't see having the successful outcome whoever sacrificed and sunset our control over contracts, pricing, what and who we see on our feed, etc seems to be hoping for. Wish it made sense, and wish all that retrofunding would have just went into creating an app experience separate from the magical goated web platforms. but i'm also thankful because this all happening at once was very eye opening and taught me a valuable lesson once again. So i'll do my best to not repeat the same bright eyed, heart full trusting mistake again. <3
500,000 $enjoy
I honestly appreciate this change, there is a world in which this can feel and look good beyond the abstract version that requires a bit more contract & token expertise than likely most artists / collectors who haven’t ventured into the defi / trading side of this universe. Even if this were fully fleshed out, simple to understand and execute to a degree that any recently onboarded (novice) user was able to digest, see the value and utilize. The elephant in the room is still the main purpose for most artists to even use a platform. Discovery / visibility / reach. If this would have rolled out months ago before changes to following / discover & the search feeds. It might have had a chance to be better received. But when the “today/new” feed is truncated to displaying only a few select mystery mints instead of real time. At the same time the following / discover user feeds are congested with seeing the same popular thing everyone is minting and at the cost of not seeing new things created by the people you follow. It makes it hard for new or existing artists, collectors to feel good about secondary markets when the same mechanics used in the legacy platforms that made pivoting even make sense. Have been implemented in an ecosystem where discovery & reach are tied to possibility of monetary incentives. and to be clear, if I was benefitting from this existing model even at the highest level it still wouldn’t feel good because it’s a transparently broken model easily manipulated. I say this all with love. I’m definitely not the only one who notices or is disappointed in this taking place. I’m just less inclined to put my self preservation over making an attempt to signal “There is glaring, unhealthy flaw” when it’s still early enough to course correct and patch the bugs.
If those unhealthy bugs aren’t an oversight & are instead the intended function. I don’t mind that being communicated directly so I don’t keep wasting time trying to hold onto Hope that this is something we can return to championing and recommending 🫂
Passion or Apathy…
Passion may not scale as quick you’d like or need but sacrificing passion in an attempt to scale Apathy…
Also doesn’t work.
Synonyms w/ Live Service Games
Passion shows praise & expresses discontent when the game the love breaks things they love after patch updates. It’s a push & pull but that’s passion and passion equals retention.
Unlike a fully realized and finalized game, Live Service lives and d*es on player retention.
The Live Service Game deathblow is the shareholder roadmap. Most of the players know the game devs love the game but shareholders & execs control the ship. This ship seems to travel down the same path. Pivot to Free to play, dumb down game to not scare possible new player experience, making long term player experience miserable. Slow bleed of passionate dedicated player base, New players come but don’t stay, Apathetic & unemotionally connected…. Game Studio let’s go of 30% of staff.
Passionate players remember how their investment of time was tossed away and voices felt unheard. Never trusts or touches future games by the studio they know makes amazing games cus they know as soon as it begins to pop off, they won’t be happy with active player base and attempt to scale, repeating the same failed play book.
If we didn’t care, we wouldn’t care so much. Passion might not scale but building for apathy is well…. Raid Shadow Legends…
Choose Your Adventure.
🫂
I don’t mind there being a secondary market, I just want all the things that made me love and trust my artifacts with Zora. Control. The ability to set Duration even if forever, edition size, pricing. And a default main feed that shows only original posts from who I follow, and my followers see my posts. And move seeing what other people (I follow or not even) to a non default feed to browse for some RNG curation after going through my following feed.
I missed so many mints from people I follow, that got drowned out by being force fed a wall of trending thing minting. I love zora, and lately it feels like zora stop loving its active user base on a mission to obtain new users.
I keep all these thoughts onchain via comments on zora. Jacob, please save the Clocktower 🫂
Appreciate your thoughts on this, My comment will be truncated unfortunately but if context in public is the format presented, I'll do my best to that format I love and appreciate justice <3
I was an artist long before I was trader, and I was a trader before I minted my first combo of Music + Photo on Rarible in Feb 2021. While the finance side of trading coins was the motivation of me deep diving w/o external motivation or peer based inspiration to learn defi, It was the PvP aspect and getting better at TA over time that made me enjoy trading. Instead of dumping all my energy into leveling up and trying to master a video game, I decided to allocate that free time into trading when my ears needed a break from creating. Over time I learned all that TA I spent time learning, really has no use where the liquidity would choose to travel to. All this to say, I love the coins, and the fact my wallet has a history woven into from my first to last trade, across chains, ecosystems and obscure narratives that are long forgotten. Proof of solo leveling in the trenches fumbling generational wealth.
Because the trading coins part exists, I never stressed the financial side of the artist documenting side. I knew very early that royalties were basically a handshake deal unless centralized which you very eloquently expanded on. So while that "selling point" to onboard artists into the ecosystem is definitely what brought a lot of artists here, I was just a tired 40 year old artist in bad health that spent 3 of those decades dedicated to releasing music since the days of aol, exhausted watching decades of building an audience and amazing history captured on the internet be reset to 0 as search engines purged search results, platforms, blogs, and websites evaporated without notice (AOL MAIL / MYSPACE) the biggest personal hits, and losing the ability to reach my own followers who always showed up no matter how long I was away living live, and no longer being served posts and art from the people I chose to follow for reason... and instead be lost in the shuffle, miss all friends posts while being bombarded by stuff I didn't sign up to see because someone I followed like, replied to something and the absolute worst part was not being able to avoid seeing the metrics and numbers attached to everything that became more valuable to society over time than the posts or art they were attached to Uneducated and Naive in hindsight, what made me hard pivot to documenting my art and story via blockchain and collecting others was the "Selling Point" it is forever, will always exist and no one can separate that media and metadata attached to it.
For the first time since 2014, there was zero negative feelings attached to sharing expression online again, Between Catalog, Foundation and Zora, I was able to browse as collector chronologically, avoid vanity metrics, have some sort of organization, reach my followers and see what my followers posted. If the platform didn't have these things, or began to lose them, they lost me over time.
Everyone is here for a different reason as an artist, collector, builder.... I understand this completely. but what I have difficulty accepting without resistance is slowly, then rapidly watching all the "selling points" used to onboard "The Artists" whom without, Media / Art based platforms would serve who? All vanish and Mirror the same broken systems that were used as a "selling point" to onboard artist.
You think algorithms in a platform make sense for mass adoption, but there is an intrinsic face slap of removing the ability to have the simple feature of having "THE DEFAULT" feed on any platform be one that shows you only original posts from the people you choose to follow. When replaced by seeing suggested posts, or being jumbled and clogged with being force fed what others like, collect, repost, comment on..... This feels bad on Legacy platforms where there is no financial incentives, just attention currency. But when this happens on any platform where visibility is tied to financial system. It feels irresponsible, since it creates unbalance in ecosystem where gaming that system and giving biased advantages while also obscuring others in the process.... I understand from a protocol and even platform level why seeing this typed out probably makes the person saying it out loud persona non grada since everyone's just trying to survive long term. but there is no universe in which you can say in your heart that what is being said isn't coming from a place of love from someone who loves art and meaningful connection through art who's love can be traced through actions signaled in the wallet that this amazing technology gives meaning to using.
The timing of this inpublic post seems cosmic. Because Content has turned the internet into a real world black mirror episode and there's zero denying that, but most importantly.... Forcing Artists to approach creative expression as a Brand works, until it doesn't. If you're interested in examples, the cosmic timing has been documented 24hrs before reading this below 🫂
ily ❤️
Thank you sincerely from one Very O.G. Internet Person to another for being so thoughtful with your Art. It’s kept me sane & grounded knowing I’m not insane for publicly expressing how unhealthy & unethical all these apps and platforms all feel. I had a glimmer of hope with new tech and how good it felt to post and share again minus algorithms & pushing what others engage with down our throats & never having to question if my own posts would be lost in a sea of RNG popularity metrics…. I guess no one building anymore is confident enough they won’t fail without following the broken model of removing chronological real time discovery & more options…. It feels bad, no matter how you package it, building for a dumbed down audience just further creates a perpetual lazy and dumbed down world.
On that note. Thank you sincerely elle. You’re a good egg. I appreciate you and I hope you realize that your presence was impactful. I will be joining you on hiatus. Tho mine will likely be Eternal. 🫂
Love - “Dutchyyy VS The Algorithms”
Here’s my full clip.
860,477 $enjoy
You are now witnessing one of the most active creators & collectors reach the end of their passion, dedication & consistency. It was a really simple concept. I loved it. But what I love, think, feel or do doesn’t move the needle. I loved being able to follow specific people & never miss what the post. I loved the false reality that this tech made sense for high effort, deep intentioned documentation.
My heart breaks watching the platforms I love, hard pivot to mimic the platforms we tried to escape. It breaks my heart instead of seeing the peoples original uploads of people I chose to follow, I’m bombarded by only seeing what’s actively being engaged with…. It breaks my heart I trusted my legacy to places that acted like they cared about my work & story when I remained active during times where there was low activity & then as soon as I passionately gave honest feedback about changes about the platforms I actively & consistently use as a creator and collector. That support was cut, & now I’m stuck watching the space I thought was on track to bring the magic back to the internet, force feed me low effort, disposable posts in a race to create Instagram 2.0. I’m heart broken I minted my own work, just so I could leave a comment on it for a better chance for the people who follow me to see it.
I’m heartbroken no one leaves the feeds to explore previous works, I’m heart broken seeing protocols drop a subpar image that trends with 50k mints when there aren’t 50k people collecting.
I’m heart broken that being open and honest about what I’m not happy with, will have a greater impact on your perceptions of me over the fact that beyond my passionate words, I’ve shown up consistently collecting and creating with love and intention to the point I’m ranked in the top 50
My wittle heart and spirit can’t keep giving and giving and showing up in places that loudly signal, I don’t belong. Godspeed w/ mass adoption. When you trade passion for apathy you end up as the live service game that lost its loyal player base in the quest for new players with no emotional investment or attachment.
Sincerely, A Token Chat sweat. Yearning to return to couch co-op & never boot up another live service “game” again.
🫂 If you can’t grasp why someone is so emotionally invested in the topics that have just been expressed.
It will all make sense soon.
When no new context is documented, the existing documenting context will connect the dots.
Optimus Prime Lost His Spark in 1987…
Sobbing that this didn’t show up in my following feed, the discovery feed or new today feed, when it should have showed up in all 3. Very Internet Fatigued
Beautiful to read.
To me, being able to cement music that's dear to your heart on the forever library is the valuable magic. Discourse, public sentiment have always been such a fickle noise signal, at the beginning and the end it always was and always will be the quiet personal journey that fuels the art of turning imagination and emotion through creative expression into something tangible in the real world. The amount of music I've created that I always didn't release or didn't love myself that ended up having deep impact on strangers changed my perspective on the value of resonance so many decades ago. It's why since I pivoted to smart contracts, I've maintained uninterrupted consistency and unwavering conviction in staying the course and never slowing down due to external factors like market price, sentiment, or public discourse. 120 1/1's on catalog since 2022 and I'm not even close to finished securing my back catalog. Things like Scarcity, Price, and all the "tradable asset" side of this technology aren't as important as the reason I choice to hard pivot in the first place.. A Forever Storage of Legacy tied to Context that will hopefully remain in tact long after I'm gone to serve as Proof of a lifetime of uninterrupted dedication, love and servitude to the love of my life. "Music"
"I Used to love H.e.r."
SCENES has been such a beautiful piece of history to witness & be apart of. What began as thoughtful vehicle to encourage a more intimate connection with the music i think ended up taking a life of it's own outside of the main focus (The Music) You had so many people, myself included submitting super personal and vulnerable photographic memories because of how clever and safe and honorable the transformation of those inputted memories were treated and the output of those SCENES alone is a magical successful experiment that elevated a collective of personal memories in such a profound way.
I think the emphasis on the SCENES might has distracted or confused people from Collecting the Music side of the project, I only say this because after speaking with Jamie (SOF) I was shocked to hear how many people who loved, championed and backed this wonderful performance art project never collected any of the songs, Including myself, because I honestly thought I already did. I missed the not so obvious detail that there were two options, collect song and collect scene. Because SOF put so much emphasis on the SCENES side of it, I wonder how many people missed collecting the music side like i did. If you're reading this and you also missed it but love this project, please take a few moments to go back and revisit the site to grab the music also <3
This was inspirational to watch unfold. Grateful I was able to witness it up close..
Dear Coop:
It ruffled feathers because when it comes to music the way you have moved and shifted narratives loudly is always as far from organic & authentic as it gets. I have no doubts you’re a fan of music, but you don’t move as someone who respects culture & or anything organic, I’m sure you’ve made the people around you money from music, but you, me & everyone else knows it’s never been organic, from botting sound, to boosts.. You’re an intelligent human & no one can deny you’re business savvy, but you’re strategies & influence are not used for good of music or artists in the ecosystem. It’s blockchain, it’s all transparent. VC’s & Founders, Protocols & Friends is who you serve. You know in your heart this an objective truth so of course you ruffled feathers, you’re the loudest voice & you have of history of not being a net positive for culture, art, music. Wish you could understand, but your actions & words have done the most harm to “this ecosystem” 🫂
Is this mic on? are my 2k + followers real humans? Is adding a “mute” function to platforms that have algorithmic feeds where reach is tied to engagement a detrimental blow to the sanity of humanity all for the sake of the cowardly action of not properly using the follow/unfollow function that worked perfectly for decades in the virtual world. Are we building the new internet responsibly or just recreating the same broken systems we tried to escape. Are humans disposable, context forsaken & the future is the dead internet theory as a result over user retention stats needed for profit to the point we lost the free internet and trusted human choice with deep insecurity that we played virtual god removing the control of the human curation by force feeding its users the most popular by engagement which has the FM radio ripple effect burying the true human spirit? Is this mic on?
First post from inside the Zora Plus (Mobile App) had to be a recovered screenshot from an ancient phone that documents consistency in isolation to protect other peoples energy.
Artists can’t ever say goodbye to creating. Trust me, 3 & half decades being a starving artist connected to the most talented audio wizards of our generation, no one ever can walk away from the sacred process of creating from imagination.. maybe a hiatus, but never goodbye. Enjoy your rest, see you on the other side 🫂
222222 $enjoy
C.Y. Drift 222222 $enjoy
Love your style 🫂 222222 $enjoy
111111 $enjoy Voidwalker <3
So so lonely…. Will be back from desktop shortly. I want all yards in “my” main wallet. 111111 $enjoy
Legendary link up in a magical land 111111 $enjoy
analog ave 111111 $enjoy
33333 $enjoy
111111 $enjoy
It was Beautiful. I feel lost again 222222 $enjoy
333333 $enjoy
111111 $enjoy
Commenting with love from this big a** airplane still
111111 $enjoy Visual sentiment
🫂
111111 $enjoy
72,575 $enjoy
<33333 574798 $enjoy
Vault explorers 333333 $enjoy
The Uproot 111111 $enjoy
Surreal Side Chain Compression 111111 $enjoy
ILY & I <3 Hiroshi 🫂 333333 $enjoy
199999 $enjoy 🤐
COLLECTING ALL THE BALLZ. 77777 $enjoy
111111 $enjoy OUI OUI
111111 $enjoy HIDE N HEAL
333333 $enjoy
FYI 🫂
111111 $enjoy
The issue isn't as simple as bots / boosts are good or bad. The "nefarious" part that everyone seems to keep leaving out is the most important part. It's the reason why I after several calls with David, I emotionally and actively stopped using or acknowledging the platform. It's the reason I've been pushing back so hard and so loudly about the changes to zora, removing the chronological follower and discover feeds, and having them replaced by activity feeds... If you want to pay to create fake demand, using bots, more power to you... I'd personally just airdrop actual humans I think might enjoy the music/art but "perceived volume" and all that jazz. THE ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM is why this ugly... Sound has a leaderboard, and they removed, the real time minting feed, by design they destroyed discoverability of all those new artists they shilled a brighter future to on tiktok and ig, and they never stood a chance, but a guy with a turtle neck controls those charts.... The same issue is now on zora, where unrealistic amount of mints keep going to the platforms posts, big projects, and friends of the inner circle... all of these things are fine in a free market, but when you manipulate discovery, and design to amplify the most active, and bury everyone else...... you can't gaslight me to make me believe the ones designing and calling the shots aren't intelligent enough to understand how broken and rigged that is.... I know without a doubt, it was by design at sound, i spoke for hours with David. It's becoming increasing more difficult to not look at Zora in the same light. They are devs, they could easily create an organic default feed that only shows original posts in the order they were minted from the people you follow and create a second feed, that has the activity mechanics.... the only reason not to do this, is as exactly how it looks, and i've screenshot and documented so many examples that's it's happening... So when I see promo about how Zora is fun, mints are better than likes, it feels like the same playback, trying to onboard a bunch of new users, who will be buried by the latest AI generated meme...... It's not bots, it's the whole picture. It's not speculation, it's not salt, it's actively happen to point it's impossible not to see. Am I the bad guy for bringing up a design flaw that so many others see and label it as "the rich get richer" scheme... This behavior on sound was detrimental the ecosystem.. So it's not the bots, it's a insider strategy that is easily abused, that doesn't just benefit the the ones getting high volume, but makes the experience for everyone else feel and look bad.... Everyone is so passive in this space, these aren't defi trading ponzi's, these are platforms centered around art, that actively market themselves as superior to the web2 experience... your integrity gotta be on empty if you try and shun the messenger for trying to stick up for the greater good of health of all users.... I don't even wanna work on music or document art after all this, so I pivoted and began documenting in detail this whole experience to create and actual documentary. No one wants to acknowledge users justified critiques, but steady reposting untrue glazing statements... tisk tisk... Naurdwuar on the case...... INCOMING 111111 $enjoy
Happy Friday Dav <3 77777 $enjoy
Super Dope! 77777 $enjoy
Blinded me with Science..... SCIENCE!!!!!! <3 111111 $enjoy
111111 $enjoy
Reminds me of The Friends of Ringo Ishikawa 111111 $enjoy
ZUNE DASHBOARD 111111 $enjoy
"Battle Mech, Robo Tech, Ready to Flex" - Apathy (Demigodz) 111111 $enjoy
"I let my tape rock, til my tape pop" 77777 $enjoy
(❁´◡`❁) 333333 $enjoy
280,017 $enjoy
Not fine, but grateful, thankful but not fine. 77777 $enjoy
Floating 111111 $enjoy
🫂 77777 $enjoy
Peak enJoy ride. 333333 $enjoy
“Music is the utility” 111111 $enjoy
🍜 222222 $enjoy
crystallized mako. “Meteor Fall” 333333 $enjoy
Time extended +++ 111111 $enjoy
Appreciate you adding to the convo. I would assume at this point, the platforms (obviously the main pain point for most creatives and artists) already are fully aware how bad this all feels for artists and creatives but also realize there aren't enough real humans using the platforms to keep the lights on, so everyone is rushing to change what made this all special in an attempt to try to scale with hopes of mass adoption, when we aren't ready for that clearly. And it seems like the ones making the calls think the ability to "possibly" make income for uploading compared to legacy web2 social is the thing that would be so intriguing to already skeptical normies, whom if did magically all onboard rn, would quickly realize, they jumped into a new ecosystem minus their existing following only to land in a void that just adopted the same broken discovery mechanisms where following and having followers have no meaning... sustainability, income are a bonus, the majority of creatives I've crossed path with the past 30 years main concern beyond the creative process is their art making meaningful connections. This mass pivot to obviously farm creatives and users for frequent traffic i can't see having the successful outcome whoever sacrificed and sunset our control over contracts, pricing, what and who we see on our feed, etc seems to be hoping for. Wish it made sense, and wish all that retrofunding would have just went into creating an app experience separate from the magical goated web platforms. but i'm also thankful because this all happening at once was very eye opening and taught me a valuable lesson once again. So i'll do my best to not repeat the same bright eyed, heart full trusting mistake again. <3 500,000 $enjoy
☔️ I’ll protect them 🐈🐈⬛ 111111 $enjoy
Reticulating Super Moon Splines 222222 $enjoy
3333 $enjoy
Inpublic, you are appreciated. Deeply.
333333 $enjoy
I missed so many mints from people I follow, that got drowned out by being force fed a wall of trending thing minting. I love zora, and lately it feels like zora stop loving its active user base on a mission to obtain new users.
I keep all these thoughts onchain via comments on zora. Jacob, please save the Clocktower 🫂
ily ❤️ Thank you sincerely from one Very O.G. Internet Person to another for being so thoughtful with your Art. It’s kept me sane & grounded knowing I’m not insane for publicly expressing how unhealthy & unethical all these apps and platforms all feel. I had a glimmer of hope with new tech and how good it felt to post and share again minus algorithms & pushing what others engage with down our throats & never having to question if my own posts would be lost in a sea of RNG popularity metrics…. I guess no one building anymore is confident enough they won’t fail without following the broken model of removing chronological real time discovery & more options…. It feels bad, no matter how you package it, building for a dumbed down audience just further creates a perpetual lazy and dumbed down world. On that note. Thank you sincerely elle. You’re a good egg. I appreciate you and I hope you realize that your presence was impactful. I will be joining you on hiatus. Tho mine will likely be Eternal. 🫂 Love - “Dutchyyy VS The Algorithms” Here’s my full clip. 860,477 $enjoy
Classic song. Dope Video! 1111 $enjoy
33333 $enjoy
next level! pulling on this gatcha immediately 111111 $enjoy
Alice in Wonderland 333333 $enjoy
111111 $enjoy
111111 $enjoy
www.youtube.com/watch?v=jgh10of6DKA
111111 $enjoy
11111 $enjoy At the clock
🫂🫂🫂🫂
26,838 $enjoy
In vitro 222222 $enjoy
“Yoyoyoyoyoyoyo!” 222222 $enjoy
#EvolvingPortals 131313 $enjoy
pipe dreams 55555 $enjoy
olfaction traction 77777 $enjoy
Peak over the top 80's villain era 88888 $enjoy
111111 $enjoy
inner visions 77777 $enjoy
I think the emphasis on the SCENES might has distracted or confused people from Collecting the Music side of the project, I only say this because after speaking with Jamie (SOF) I was shocked to hear how many people who loved, championed and backed this wonderful performance art project never collected any of the songs, Including myself, because I honestly thought I already did. I missed the not so obvious detail that there were two options, collect song and collect scene. Because SOF put so much emphasis on the SCENES side of it, I wonder how many people missed collecting the music side like i did. If you're reading this and you also missed it but love this project, please take a few moments to go back and revisit the site to grab the music also <3
This was inspirational to watch unfold. Grateful I was able to witness it up close..
womb ost 7777 $enjoy
:::insert smallville theme song here::: 131313 $enjoy
So dope! 111111 $enjoy
Always Enjoy 77777 $enjoy
🌱🫂🌱 111111 $enjoy
soundcloud.com/deejayele/03-loft-music-dutchy
A captured moment in time, seen through SCENES
111111 $Enjoy
Ily 137,195 $enjoy
Those were the times 🫂🫂🫂🫂 111111 $enjoy
Sidechain Sadness 111111 $enjoy
Surreal Timing 🫂 37773 $enjoy Songcamp Genesis
(┬┬﹏┬┬) 33333 $enjoy
SP1200 cardiovascular love potion incoming 11111 $enjoy
Bit crushed rem cycles 33333 $enjoy
👻⬅️🍃🛣️←🫂 33333 $enjoy
🍱🍣🍱🍣🍱 33333 $enjoy
Each One Teach One +++ 33333 $enjoy
33333 $enjoy
Rift Drifting 6000 $enjoy
33333 $enjoy
Loop Sessions. "Sings the Smallville theme song" 131313 $enjoy
✌️✌️🙏 131131 $enjoy
Happy Friday.
33333 $enjoy
Artists can’t ever say goodbye to creating. Trust me, 3 & half decades being a starving artist connected to the most talented audio wizards of our generation, no one ever can walk away from the sacred process of creating from imagination.. maybe a hiatus, but never goodbye. Enjoy your rest, see you on the other side 🫂 222222 $enjoy
Token Chat - Help make something Magical happen below <3
beta.catalog.works/dutchyyy/crate-escape-w-i-p-f-thxk-u
11111 $enjoy
Digital to physical to Digital 1111 $enjoy
Music +++ 11111 $enjoy